13 Comments

What a fantastic summary of the evening---and Jared Peatman does a great job with the CWI scholarship students for the entire week. We have a distinct curriculum for them. Having the students read the letters in the field helps them make a powerful connection to the place. I should note that many CWI scholarship students have gone into the historical profession, include NPS chief of interp at Gettysburg--Chris Gwinn

Expand full comment

Jared does a great job with the students. I had a chance to talk with just about all of them over the course of the conference. I do hope they consider Gettysburg College.

Expand full comment

I almost went this year but schedule and finances did not let me...

Expand full comment

Next year’s theme will be Civil War atrocity. Should be interesting.

Expand full comment

Yes that would be very interesting.

Expand full comment

I've been to Gettysburg twice, and was really struck by how serene it was and the contrast with the event it's commemorating. The last time I was there, I did a bus tour on my last morning and the interpretation was incredible. Just an amazing job explaining the battle, the impact to the town, and the meaning of the battle. Tours like that are truly an artform. Thanks for sharing this experience.

Expand full comment

We currently live in Baltimore and routinely go to Gettysburg... and I have often thought much the same. What a stark contrast between the lovely bucolic scenes and the bloody chaos of the battle.

Expand full comment

I think your comment about appreciating the scope of the violence that occurred at these places is interesting. Thinking about the Civil War sites I have visited most are, as you and your friend Pete , point out today incredibely peaceful and contemplative places. But for a few brief moments in our history, very important moments, they were witness to some of the most violent and horrific things humans can do to each other. All done in defense of ideas about what our culture should be. How do you communicate that? I have tried a couple of times and don't think I have done so particularly well. It sounds as if your friend Pete is good at doing so.

Expand full comment

There are plenty of people who can lead a battlefield tour and explain what took place and how events unfolded. They can do it in ways that are entertaining and educational, but I think it takes years of careful thinking as well as trial and error to master the skill. Pete has done just that in my opinion.

Expand full comment

Thank you so much for this!!! I have never met Peter Carmichael, but your observations of him makes me strive to be a better teacher. (Oh, I wish I was there!)

Expand full comment

You should really think about registering for next year's conference. I have no doubt that you will have an incredible time.

Expand full comment

Wow, Kevin! Peter's tour and student exercise sounds amazing. I'd love to have been there. This is what teaching history is all about. Those students will have, and share, these experiences and knowledge for the next 60-70 years. Imagine that impact. WOW!! Thank you for sharing this experience.

Expand full comment

Think about registering for next year's conference. You will love it.

Expand full comment