18 Comments

Thanks to everyone for the tips! I still have the Longstreet book on my TBR pile.

I loved the illustrations for this post, as I have actually read most of these books. A tiny nit to pick: I'd prefer a shot of C. Vann Woodward's edition of Mary Chesnut's "diary", even though it's less photogenic, as it makes so clear Chesnut's efforts to shape her book, rather than just artlessly jotting down her thoughts in an amazingly prescient way. Also, it contains all the "diary" content, not pruned as thought appropriate by Chesnut's friends or later editors.

Expand full comment

It's a remarkable inside account of the Civil War. One of those books that I need to replace because of overuse.

Expand full comment

I also liked:On Great Fields: The Life and Unlikely Heroism of Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain by Ronald White

Expand full comment

I also enjoyed it.

Expand full comment

I enjoyed : The Rise and Fall of the Second American Republic: Reconstruction, 1860-1920 by Manisha Sinha

Expand full comment

Still working my way through this one.

Expand full comment

George Rable's Conflict of Command was the best I read this year.

Expand full comment

I've read through most of it. Another solid study by Rable. Thanks, Michael.

Expand full comment

I read "The Unvanquished" by Patrick K. O'Donnell and thought was really good. A completely new look at what had seemed well-trod territory. Erik Larson's "Demon of Unrest" was an enjoyable read, and like all of his works, focused on the human and personal aspects. For post post-Civil War, Fergus M. Bordewich's "Klan War" was a much-needed history of the rise of the KKK, its destruction by Grant and Merrill, and its eventual resurrection in the early 1900s. Bordewich also tells the story of how Reconstruction did not "fail," it was killed by political corruption and fecklessness.

Expand full comment

Hi Roger,

I am unfamiliar with O'Donnell's book. Will definitely check it out. Thanks.

Expand full comment

An Unholy Traffic is the one that really jumps out to me.

Expand full comment

Such a good book. Here is my review with the author in case you missed it. https://kevinmlevin.substack.com/p/a-conversation-with-historian-robert?utm_source=publication-search

Expand full comment

Yes! I really enjoyed this conversation.

Expand full comment

I thought Elizabeth Varon’s book on Longstreet was outstanding. I also appreciated Fergus Bordewich’s Klan War. Not exactly Civil War but Civil War-adjacent

Expand full comment

Thanks for making these mention. I've ordered Varon's book and somehow will find for it the top of my best stack of pending-to-read CW books. (Wife and I are also binge-revenge-watching the presidential campaign of our local-former-DA-about-to-rescue-America.)

The Pandemic created the space for me to study in-depth my favorite battle, then to grow more attentive to its being the root (or taproot, at least?) of The Lost Cause and then to how those lying liars assassinated JL's character as their route to faux-resurrecting REL's character as the Patron Saint of Enslavers. (Anybody seen any books on Lee's rotten officer corps management style?)

Thus, now I am attempting to catch up on JL's true life. Maybe then, Bordewich's book. (Then, KML's book-in-process on Shaw!)

Expand full comment

Hi Margaret,

Both are excellent books. I am going to try to interview Liz Varon in November to mark the publication of her Longstreet bio in paperback.

Expand full comment

I really enjoyed reading “Silent Cavalry” and “Unholy Traffic”. I also found it intriguing that essay formatted books were making a small comeback this year with “Limits of the Lost Cause”, “The War that Made America”, and “The Civil War and the Summer of 2020”

Expand full comment

Hi Sam,

All great choices. I was also impressed with the quality of edited essay collections this year as well.

Expand full comment