Civil War reenacting has taken a hit over the past few years, owing to the controversy surrounding the Confederate battle flag, the hobby’s aging population, and an evolving Civil War memory that now emphasizes the history of slavery and emancipation.
Recently, two African-American entertainers traveled to Kentucky to take part in what appears to be a small Civil War reenactment. They attended dressed as and ready to play the role of slaves.
The results are predictable. The white participants are clearly flustered by the presence of these two men, who claim as much historical authenticity as those dressed in Civil War uniforms.
At one point the two drop to their knees and begin ‘picking’ cotton.
To demonstrate that they are not racists or misrepresenting the past, the reenactors literally trot out a Black man in Confederate uniform on horseback. It’s a wonderful example of how the myth of the Black Confederate has long been used to shield Lost Cause advocates from charges of racism.
I was not ready for that.
Eventually the police show up and force the two to leave the grounds.
All in all, it was a pretty funny attempt to undercut a Civil War reenactment and its participants, who are still clearly mired in the Lost Cause.
If you are like me, the video may have reminded you of this hilarious skit from the comedy team of Key & Peele.
Enjoy.
I love civil war reenactments, but when they provide some ridiculous cover for what the war was actually about, then it becomes nothing more than a racist exercise in Lost Cause nonsense. I remember one of the reenactments I went to when I was a kid had a faux surgeon demonstrating the pain of what the civil war wounded went through and they were in character the entire time talking about the anger they felt at watching young men die for slavers. It was incredibly educational.
Props to these two men for having the guts to call out the pseudo-historical bros of reenactment. Reenactment should be historical and educational, not a club.
Good for them! As Thoreau said, "Any TRUTH is better than make believe."